Accueil » News » Human Centered Design to understand the uses and needs of menstrual health in Senegal

Human Centered Design to understand the uses and needs of menstrual health in Senegal

Context and design challenge

In Senegal, most young girls are not well prepared for their first period. The difficulties they encounter stem mainly from:

  • the weight of taboos – In the family and social circle, menstruation is often seen as something dirty and shameful.
  • Young women don’t know who to talk to when they have questions.  The attitude of those around them makes them feel insecure: they don’t dare discuss these subjects with them.  So they prefer to talk about it with their friends – which can create a risk of transmitting beliefs and information that are often incorrect.
  • Difficulty to access information about the menstrual cycle.
  • Lack of access to quality, affordable menstrual protection.
  • a lack of decent, safe toilets in public places, including schools
  • a lack of information and services to help manage the pain and discomfort associated with the menstrual cycle.

With the aim of better supporting young women through this very important stage of their lives, the social enterprise ApiAfrique , founded in 2017, has made menstrual cycle management a priority by developing:

  • a range of healthy and sustainable hygiene products for women and babies – in particular menstrual pads and organic cotton washable baby nappies.
  • the menstrual cycle information program “Break the Cycle

The lack of access to accurate and reliable information about the menstrual cycle and the difficulty of predicting the onset of periods and preparing for them are key issues. Logically, given the use of digital tools by this target group, the focus has shifted towards the creation of a mobile application that is more accessible to young girls.

With this in mind, in 2021, ApiAfrique, in its desire to better reach young women, established a partnership with IT4Life, a digital service company that supports social economy organisations in their digital transformation. Together, they contacted YUX, a pan-African design and research agency, to form a consortium with the Dakar Institute of Technologie and IDinsight. This consortium won the Botnar Foundation’s “Fit for the future 2021” call for projects to scale up the program initiated by ApiAfrique.

From there, the process of creating tailored, human-centred solutions was launched. This article describes the human-centred design approach, coordinated by YUX , for the change of scale of Break the Cycle.

The Human Centered Design approach

YUX, whose ambition is to democratize design and co-create digital products and services adapted to the diversity of African users, has implemented the Human Centered Design (HCD) approach with the following guiding principles :

  • an iterative methodology
  • involving multidisciplinary teams
  • guided by the explicit understanding of users
  • human-centered evaluation.

The HCD applied in the Break the Cycle project took place in the following stages:

1.Planning

In human-centered research, one of the crucial phases is planning. This is when the timeline and logistics of the project are decided with the consortium. This is when the core project team is identified and tasks and dependencies between teams are assigned. This is also the time to discuss the different channels of communication for collaboration, as well as deadlines and deliverables. If neglected, this stage can have serious consequences for the progress of the project.

2.Exploration

The main research issue was to understand how young women manage their menstrual cycle, the factors influencing this management and the impact on their lives. The research was carried out using a format of individual, non-directive interviews. 

We conducted 12 interviews lasting about an hour with 6 young women aged between 15 and 20 and 6 others aged between 21 and 24, all of whom were literate and educated. The interviews were conducted between Dakar and Mbour. 

To put the young women at ease, we created a ‘safe space’, a place where people can feel comfortable and confident to talk about subjects that interest them. Every effort is made to establish a climate of mutual trust, and the choice of environment is certainly important, but more than that, the people with whom the target group will be interacting must be hand-picked. In this “safe space”, the young women were able to decide on the various subjects they wished to discuss in confidence – subjects of particular concern to them.

The time spent welcoming them, putting them at ease, introducing the subject and the purpose of the interviews was of vital importance in building the young women’s confidence and willingness to make the subject their own. 

The aim of the interviews was to establish themes while following the natural impulse of the young women to tell us what was important to them. We began by looking at the general profile of the young woman, her family background and her use of digital technology. Next, we guided her through the memories of her first period: whether or not she had been prepared for it, identifying her circle of trust and knowing what information was important to her at this stage. 

Finally, we looked at how she currently manages her menstrual health, focusing on her preferred sources of information and people she trusts. From there, we listed the different types of information and the most appropriate formats for transmitting them.

 

 

3.Definition

The interviews provided a wealth of information. Following an initial analysis, we identified 4 profiles of young women: 

The ingenue : who knows the minimum but thinks it’s “shameful” to want to know more. She would lose her “good girl” status if she tried to find out more.

The older sister : Doesn’t want her younger sisters to go down the same road as her. She needs to share her experience to help.

The prepared sister : Is very comfortable with the subject. They want to interact and talk with their peers and professionals.

Those who think they know enough: who think they’ve covered everything and don’t expect to be surprised if there’s still more to discover – they’re not aware of it.

Key insights 

Here are a few findings that summarize the feedback from the interviews :

a) The people around them have a strong influence on young women’s perception of menstruation. Girls who come from families where they can ask questions about menstruation without constraint do more research on the subject and have a better experience of this period.

Elles subissent quand même la They are still under pressure to be chaste, however, and once they start their period, a familiar refrain becomes: “Stay away from boys or you’ll get pregnant”.

These words not only cause stress but also have an impact on young women’s confidence in boys in an environment they share. Nervousness and sometimes aggression can creep into relationships.

b) Young women start using phones as children and have their own phones by adolescence. Even if some of them start with a touch-tone phone, the transition to the smartphone happens fairly quickly. They are very independent when it comes to social networks and mobile applications in general. For some, the best source of information on menstruation and menstrual health remains the Google search engine.

c) Most young women are not prepared for the arrival of their first period. Lack of preparation is seen as a handicap, a mixture of incomprehension and shame at having to talk about it. The most curious seek to find out more and compare their experiences with those of their friends.

However, for many of them, the best course of action is to stick to what their mother, aunt or grandmother tells them.

These young women are not aware of the lack of information and are just embarrassed to be curious. They are afraid of being seen as the young woman who wants sexual freedom rather than simply the young woman who wants information about her body.

d) The information that young women gather around them has an impact on their menstrual management. Myths, legends and misinformation are often at the top of the list. For young women, everything that close family and friends say is true. Few compare it with other sources before applying it.

e) Most young women think they have a role to play in preparing younger women for menstruation. They feel that it is unacceptable to let younger women experience their first period without anyone to talk to them about it beforehand. They don’t want what happened to them in terms of lack of information and support to be perpetuated in younger women, even if it means that they themselves play the role of big sister in the process.

4. Ideation

Armed with these lessons about the relevance of a mobile application to inform and support young women about menstrual health, we organised creativity sessions with the Break the Cycle  consortium to generate the various functionalities that seemed to meet users’ needs. Using problem trees, brainstorming and a prioritisation matrix, we came up with features to be tested with users.

Following this, 2 co-creation workshops were held with teenage girls and young women in Dakar and Mbour to get a diversity of profiles. A card sorting exercise was carried out with the young women to test the understanding and relevance of the functionalities, improve them and create new ones.  Once all the cards had been sorted, the young women prioritised them according to their needs and together they built the information architecture of the application, ensuring that it was adapted to their needs.

5. Prototypage et les tests

Partant de cette vision des utilisatrices, nous avons prototypé sur Figma une maquette low fidelity pour tester la pertinence, la compréhension des écrans ainsi que la navigation naturelle des utilisatrices. Ces premiers tests ont été réalisés avec 7 jeunes femmes à Dakar. 

Les retours de test ont été agrégés en un document synthétique avec des recommandations ciblées – ce qui a permis une itération pour améliorer le prototype et partir sur le design d’interface. Le UI a donc fait évoluer le prototype en associant les éléments graphiques, le logo, une hypothèse de wording ainsi que le look & feel de l’application.

Puis, une autre série de tests utilisateurs a été réalisée avec 9 jeunes femmes entre Dakar et Mbour pour valider nos idées et propositions.  La récurrence et la pertinence du point de blocage  a été mesuré en groupe pour juger à quel point il impactait l’expérience utilisateur. Une priorisation des retours de 0 (pas de problème d’utilisabilité) à 5 (problème d’utilisabilité urgent) a été réalisée puis  suivie de recommandations pour une meilleure expérience utilisateur. Cette priorisation a permis  au designer d’identifier les points sur lesquels il est urgent de se focaliser pour une prochaine version. 

Enfin, fort de ces derniers retours, une dernière itération a été faite avec le consortium pour implémenter les derniers retours et partager tous les éléments du design dont  le design system et le prototype high fidelity pour que l’équipe de développement puisse prendre en charge de manière fluide et coordonnée le prototype. 

Résultats et enseignements 

Sur ce projet, deux aspects ont été particulièrement impactants : 

  1. L’implication des jeunes à toutes les étapes du projet: collaborer avec les jeunes filles dans des projets qui les concernent est un moyen efficace de garder en vue leurs besoins, de les accompagner et de les habituer à la prise de décision mais aussi de leur inculquer des process inclusives et innovants pour relever des défis et répondre à des problématiques qui les concernent.
  2. Impliquer des partenaires peu familiers au processus HCD est une belle manière de sensibiliser à l’utilisation de nos outils.  Dans un premier temps pour comprendre les problématiques et contexte et prendre en compte les besoins pour l’élaboration de solutions. Dans un second temps, fidèle à notre ambition, pour démocratiser le design dans l’espoir que ces partages de méthodologies sèment les graines pour plus de projets centrés sur l’humain et que la création s’inspire au mieux des besoins. 

Article rédigé par Aissatou DIONE (YUX)
Photo : Animation de lancement de l’application WeerWi (crédit : CLR)